St. James Homes and Condos for Sale

On the North Shore of Long Island you will find the Town of Smithtown, New York. Situated in Suffolk County, Smithtown is home to approximately 117,801 residents as of the 2010 Census. Within Smithtown you’ll find a census-designated place by the same name, as well as a charming hamlet and CDP known as St. James, New York. St. James the CDP is home to approximately 13,338 residents and is found in the 11780 zip code of Smithtown.

St. James was a thriving vacation hotspot in the early 20th century. Summer residents during that time included none other than Ethel, Lionel, John Barrymore, Myrna Loy, Irving Berlin and Buster Keaton. This delightful community has a rich history and is said to be home to the oldest continuously operating general store in the nation, the St. James General Store located on Moriches Road. It is also home to numerous structures that have been added to the National Register of Historic Places. Composed of 4.5 square miles, all land, St. James is south of St. James Harbor and east of the hamlet of Smithtown.

Homes for sale in St. James, New York, come in a broad price range and include properties of varying ages, sizes and architectural styles. Co-ops in St. James have an average listing price around $322,500, while condos and townhomes in St. James have an average listing price near $536,000. Multi-family homes in St. James have an average listing price around $379,000 and single family homes for sale in St. James have an average listing price near $709,500. Vacant lots and plots of land in St. James vary in price depending upon the land’s location and size. The average listing price for a lot in St. James is around $759,900.

If you would like to learn more about the homes for sale in St. James, New York, please do not hesitate to contact us today.

Latest St. James Homes and Condos for Sale

1 Swan Place, Nissequogue — No $15,750,000

SWAN MANOR! Perfectly Situated On Just Over Nine Lush Private Acres In The Heart Of Nissequogue Lies This Magnificent Gated Estate With Grand Scale Elegance. Meticulously...

14 Beds
15 Baths
3506883 MLS
No Bldg.

2 Wallis Lane, Nissequogue $10,600,000

SOMERSET. Inspired by the Governor's Palace in Williamsburg, VA, this notable estate was completed in 1935 and remains a crown jewel of Long Island's fabled North Shore. ...

7 Beds
6 Baths
3262013 MLS

12 Pheasant Run, Nissequogue — No $4,999,000

A Unique Opportunity Awaits You On This 2 Plus Acre Property To Build Your New Luxury Home On A Cul-De-Sac, And Bordering A Private Beach On The North Shore Of Long Islan...

5 Beds
6 Baths
3458787 MLS
No Bldg.

9 Pine Point, Nissequogue — No $3,499,000 ▼

This Is A Rare Opportunity To Own One Of The Most Magnificent Properties In The Village Of Nissequogue. Every Element Of This Home Was Custom-Built To The Highest Standar...

4 Beds
6 Baths
3489857 MLS
No Bldg.

435 River Road, Saint James $1,595,000

Welcome to this Completely Renovated Luxurious & Spacious private Retreat, a Colonial located in the community of Nissequogue. This 5 Bedroom, 3 Full Bathroom & 2 Half Ba...

5 Beds
5 Baths
3518987 MLS

35 Monterrey Drive Unit #35, Saint James image

35 Monterrey Drive Unit #35, Saint James — The Hamlet Estates $1,579,999

Looking For Privacy In A Gated Community? Look No Further! This Amazing 5/6 Bed, 3.5 Bath, 3 Car Garage Colonial Home On A Beautifully Landscaped 0.41 Acre Corner Lot, Su...

5 Beds
4 Baths
3518920 MLS
The Hamlet Estates Bldg.

769 Middle Country Road, Saint James image

769 Middle Country Road, Saint James $1,575,000 ▼

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! Huge 31,798 Sqft. Multi-Use Corner Development Site For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, ...

3455726 MLS

326A River Road, Saint James $1,499,000

To be built! Use owners plans or bring your own! This 2.1 acre lot on the Nissequogue River is approved and ready to go! Wonderful country setting only minutes to beaches...

5 Beds
4 Baths
3399214 MLS

15 Stillwater Road, Nissequogue — Stillwater Estates $1,399,000

Great value in an estate setting! Welcome to this beautiful and recently renovated center hall colonial located on 2+ level acres in the private Village of Nissequogue. T...

6 Beds
5 Baths
3510016 MLS
Stillwater Estates Bldg.

2 Old Mill Path, Nissequogue $1,399,000 ▼

Located in the sought after Village of Nissequogue within the city of Saint James and within the Town of Smithtown. The home sits on a privately owned cul-de-sac. This On...

4 Beds
3 Baths
3486656 MLS

1 Friends Way, Head Of Harbor $1,350,000 ▼

Artist/ Musician Haven at Lavender Hill Farm ~ Experience a Serene, Exclusive 2.56 Acreage lifestyle that has it All. Bringing Space and Style to its list of many special...

4 Beds
4 Baths
3478846 MLS

4 Smith Lane, Nissequogue $1,349,000

Welcome to this Luxurious & Spacious private Retreat, a Colonial located in the community of Nissequogue. This 5 Bedroom & 4bth home offers modern architectural style em...

5 Beds
4 Baths
3510300 MLS

23 Hamlet Woods Drive, Saint James image

23 Hamlet Woods Drive, Saint James — Hamlet Estates $1,250,000

Absolute Perfection! Welcome home to this gorgeous and enormous 4446 square foot Hampton model home in the luxurious Hamlet Estates. This 24/7 HOA gated community has eve...

5 Beds
5 Baths
3508097 MLS
Hamlet Estates Bldg.