Bay Shore Real Estate Search

Address Search

Bay Shore Homes and Condos for Sale

Welcome to Bay Shore, a charming hamlet nestled in the Town of Islip, Suffolk County, on the picturesque south shore of central Long Island, New York. With a population of 26,337 residents as of the 2010 census, Bay Shore offers a blend of historical allure and modern convenience across its 5.5 square miles.

Bay Shore boasts a rich history dating back to its purchase by John Mowbray from the Secatogue Native Americans, commemorated in 2008 during the town's 300th anniversary celebration. Once renowned for its shopping districts and resorts in the late 19th century, Bay Shore attracted affluent New Yorkers seeking respite from city life, drawn to its white sand beaches and quaint fishing villages along the Great South Bay.

Bay Shore has evolved into a beloved hometown for families, offering a tranquil suburban setting with access to urban amenities. The Bay Shore Union Free School District provides quality education to the majority of local students, ensuring a nurturing environment for academic growth.

Since the 1980s, Bay Shore has undergone a transformative redevelopment, revitalizing its landscape and enhancing its appeal. Dilapidated structures have been replaced with modern condominiums, while historic landmarks like the local theater and opera house have been repurposed to serve the community's evolving needs, such as housing the local YMCA. Main Street continues to undergo revitalization efforts, with new businesses flourishing and the Bay Shore Beautification Society adding to the town's charm with initiatives like the stunning meditation garden on Main Street.

Bay Shore offers a diverse range of properties to suit various lifestyles and preferences. From condominiums and townhomes to single-family homes and vacant lots for custom builds, the real estate market caters to a wide spectrum of buyers. The average listing price for a condo in Bay Shore is approximately $469,500, with single-family homes averaging around $363,750. Vacant lots present an opportunity for those seeking to build their dream home, with average prices hovering around $179,350. However, prices can vary based on factors such as property size and proximity to water, with premium properties commanding prices upwards of $1,299,000.

Bay Shore offers an array of amenities to enrich residents' lives, including a vibrant dining scene showcasing diverse cuisines, shopping options ranging from boutique stores to well-known brands, and an abundance of local attractions and recreational activities. Whether you're exploring the town's historical landmarks, enjoying waterfront activities on the Great South Bay, or indulging in culinary delights at one of Bay Shore's renowned eateries, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

If you're considering making Bay Shore your home, now is the perfect time to explore the diverse real estate offerings and experience the unique blend of history, community spirit, and modern conveniences that this charming hamlet has to offer. Contact us today to embark on your journey to finding your dream home in Bay Shore, New York.

Latest Bay Shore Homes and Condos for Sale

170 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore image

170 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore $3,399,000 ▼

3 Beds
3 Baths
1032772 MLS

100 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore $3,350,000

5 Beds
5 Baths
973534 MLS

375-381. #8,11,12,26,28. East Main Street, Bay Shore image

375-381. #8,11,12,26,28. East Main Street, Bay Shore $2,999,000 ▼

L3383141 MLS

24 Cottage Avenue, Bay Shore $2,489,999

1052270 MLS

193 W Main, Bay Shore $2,400,000

1032073 MLS

45 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore $2,200,000

10 Beds
7 Baths
1037620 MLS

Lot 4 and Lot 11 Overlea Court, Bay Shore image

Lot 4 and Lot 11 Overlea Court, Bay Shore $2,100,000

1007856 MLS

64 Mowbray Avenue, Bay Shore $2,000,000

9 Beds
9 Baths
1040354 MLS

64 Mowbray Avenue, Bay Shore $2,000,000

1035730 MLS

Lot 6 Overlea Court, Bay Shore $1,800,000

1007814 MLS

Lot 5 Overlea Court, Bay Shore $1,600,000

1007846 MLS

63 Holly Walk, Bay Shore $1,599,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1054495 MLS

75 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore $1,549,000 ▼

6 Beds
4 Baths
1045401 MLS

202 Captains Way, Bay Shore $1,500,000

2 Beds
2 Baths
1011815 MLS

2 Garner Lane, Bay Shore $1,500,000

967346 MLS

9 Dove Lane, Bay Shore $1,499,990

5 Beds
4 Baths
1001324 MLS

70 Park Avenue, Bay Shore $1,400,000 ▼

951712 MLS

6 Montgomery Lane, Bay Shore $1,099,999

3 Beds
3 Baths
1032442 MLS

84 Oak Walk, Bay Shore $1,050,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1062487 MLS

100A Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore $999,000 ▼

976095 MLS

1813 5th Avenue, Bay Shore $999,000

965771 MLS

174 Anchor Lane, Bay Shore $995,000

3 Beds
3 Baths
1050538 MLS

19 Joan Road, Bay Shore $949,990

4 Beds
5 Baths
1017682 MLS

906 Thompson Drive, Bay Shore $934,900

5 Beds
4 Baths
1059950 MLS

40 Muncey Road, Bay Shore $899,999

5 Beds
4 Baths
1065288 MLS

87 Bayway Avenue, Bay Shore $899,998

3 Beds
2 Baths
1048854 MLS

1641 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore $899,000

5 Beds
4 Baths
1029811 MLS

70 Massachusetts Avenue, Bay Shore image

70 Massachusetts Avenue, Bay Shore $865,000 ▼

6 Beds
5 Baths
1013421 MLS

124 Ithaca Street, Bay Shore $849,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1064788 MLS

893 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $829,000 ▼

5 Beds
4 Baths
1040238 MLS

1624 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore $799,999

4 Beds
3 Baths
1005955 MLS

655 Hyman Avenue, Bay Shore $799,000

4 Beds
3 Baths
1057032 MLS

35 Joyces Way, Bay Shore $774,990

2 Beds
3 Baths
1065692 MLS

4 Lee Avenue, Bay Shore $765,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1062484 MLS

110 N Park Avenue, Bay Shore $735,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1050572 MLS

122 Jordan Street, Bay Shore $735,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1023925 MLS

16 West Drive, Bay Shore $730,000 ▼

5 Beds
3 Baths
1040683 MLS

247 Delaware Avenue, Bay Shore $725,000

6 Beds
3 Baths
1066009 MLS

14 Perkal Street, Bay Shore $700,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
1066805 MLS

14 Perkal Street, Bay Shore $700,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
1066803 MLS

116 S Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore $700,000

4 Beds
2 Baths
1062728 MLS

48 Ellen Street, Bay Shore $699,999

4 Beds
2 Baths
1035636 MLS

30 Torrey Pine Lane, Bay Shore $699,900

2 Beds
3 Baths
1059661 MLS

991 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $699,000 ▼

3 Beds
2 Baths
1062234 MLS

1073 Oakneck Road, Bay Shore $699,000

3 Beds
3 Baths
1062312 MLS

1369 N Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore $690,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1056795 MLS

7 E Lakeland Street, Bay Shore $689,999

4 Beds
2 Baths
1040915 MLS

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1316 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore $679,500

2 Beds
2 Baths
1064716 MLS

1320 Pine Acres Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1320 Pine Acres Boulevard, Bay Shore $679,000 ▼

4 Beds
2 Baths
1046243 MLS

1385 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $675,000 ▼

3 Beds
2 Baths
1056834 MLS

1431 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1431 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore $669,900 ▼

4 Beds
2 Baths
1027830 MLS

182 New York Avenue, Bay Shore $669,000 ▼

4 Beds
2 Baths
1029207 MLS

3 Hickory Place, Bay Shore $660,000 ▼

3 Beds
2 Baths
1029205 MLS

1596 E Forks Road, Bay Shore $649,999

4 Beds
3 Baths
1065960 MLS

54 Oneill Avenue, Bay Shore $649,950

6 Beds
2 Baths
1045756 MLS

1660 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $640,000

5 Beds
3 Baths
1063729 MLS

11 Oakmont Lane, Bay Shore $639,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1065652 MLS

1327 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1327 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore $630,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1054812 MLS

1364 5th Avenue, Bay Shore $629,000 ▼

3 Beds
1 Baths
1050489 MLS

35 Circle Lane, Bay Shore $625,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1062734 MLS

1306 Potter Boulevard, Bay Shore $625,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
1059920 MLS

1182 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore $619,900

3 Beds
1 Baths
1058710 MLS

19 Chapman Place, Bay Shore $600,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1037368 MLS

1009 Joselson Avenue, Bay Shore $599,999

2 Beds
2 Baths
1065402 MLS

1023 Udall Road, Bay Shore $599,999 ▼

3 Beds
1 Baths
1038855 MLS

243 Vermont Avenue, Bay Shore $599,000

4 Beds
3 Baths
1056531 MLS

1801 Stein Drive, Bay Shore $599,000

4 Beds
1 Baths
1062130 MLS

1442 Baldwin Boulevard, Bay Shore $599,000 ▼

3 Beds
2 Baths
1058240 MLS

1556 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $599,000 ▼

3 Beds
1 Baths
1046781 MLS

1016 Howells Road, Bay Shore $595,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
979652 MLS

1013 Merriam Road, Bay Shore $590,000

3 Beds
2 Baths
999675 MLS

1024 Howells Road, Bay Shore $569,999

2 Beds
1 Baths
1053085 MLS

1533 Agate Street, Bay Shore $560,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1014509 MLS

1612 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $555,000 ▼

3 Beds
2 Baths
1037951 MLS

70 E Lakeland Street, Bay Shore $525,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1007871 MLS

1761 Manatuck Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1761 Manatuck Boulevard, Bay Shore $510,000 ▲

4 Beds
2 Baths
1062298 MLS

263 N 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore $499,999

2 Beds
2 Baths
1045766 MLS

1632 N Thompson Drive, Bay Shore $499,999

3 Beds
1 Baths
1016593 MLS

8 Juliet Street, Bay Shore $499,000

2 Beds
1 Baths
1056774 MLS

1656 N Thompson Drive, Bay Shore $499,000 ▼

3 Beds
1 Baths
1037958 MLS

1718 N Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore $495,000 ▼

4 Beds
1 Baths
1030738 MLS

94 Smith Avenue, Bay Shore $479,999

3 Beds
2 Baths
1065005 MLS

1058 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore $465,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1064941 MLS

1056 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore $460,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1063670 MLS

1619 Brightshore Boulevard, Bay Shore image

1619 Brightshore Boulevard, Bay Shore $450,000

3 Beds
1 Baths
1025583 MLS

300 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore $425,000

1030250 MLS

1699 5th Avenue, Bay Shore $425,000 ▼

948449 MLS

1515 Emkay Street, Bay Shore $409,900 ▼

4 Beds
2 Baths
1059033 MLS

Bay Place, Bay Shore $399,000 ▼

993272 MLS

44 Pinebrook Place Unit #44, Bay Shore image

44 Pinebrook Place Unit #44, Bay Shore $299,000 ▼

1 Beds
1 Baths
1060824 MLS

150 Newbrook Lane Unit #150, Bay Shore image

150 Newbrook Lane Unit #150, Bay Shore $299,000 ▼

1 Beds
1 Baths
1060815 MLS

157 Newbrook Lane Unit #157, Bay Shore image

157 Newbrook Lane Unit #157, Bay Shore $299,000 ▼

1 Beds
1 Baths
1051159 MLS

Brentwood Street, Bay Shore $280,000 ▼

866430 MLS

5 Pinebrook Place Unit #5, Bay Shore image

5 Pinebrook Place Unit #5, Bay Shore $250,000

1 Beds
1 Baths
998031 MLS

1 E Hemlock Drive Unit ##162, Bay Shore image

1 E Hemlock Drive Unit ##162, Bay Shore $220,000

1 Beds
1 Baths
1026014 MLS

5A Hemlock Drive, Bay Shore $219,000

1 Beds
1 Baths
975726 MLS

1 Hemlock Drive Unit #F164, Bay Shore image

1 Hemlock Drive Unit #F164, Bay Shore $209,999

1 Beds
1 Baths
1052975 MLS

Manatuck Boulevard, Bay Shore $200,000

1036038 MLS

Bay Shore $150,000

1061321 MLS

Bay Shore $150,000

983673 MLS

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Bay Shore Real Estate Search

Address Search

Bay Shore Homes and Condos for Sale

Latest Bay Shore Homes and Condos for Sale

Town of Hempstead

Town of Oyster Bay

City of Long Beach

City of Glen Cove

Town of Babylon

Town of Brookhaven

Town of Huntington

Town of Smithtown

Town of Islip

Town of Southhampton

Town of East Hampton

Town of Shelter Island

Town of Riverhead

Town of Southold

Town of North Hempstead

The Best in Nassau, Suffolk, & Hamptons, NY Real Estate

Pesce & Lanzillotta Team

Search Long Island Real Estate

Quick Links