Long Island Real Estate | Long Island Homes for Sale
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • Map Search
  • What's My Home Worth?
  • Sellers
  • Meet The Team
  • Blog
Login
516-888-9711

Sign in to your account

Need to reset your phone number?

Don't have an account with us?

Click here to sign up.

Middle Island Real Estate Search

TO
Advanced Search

Address Search

Middle Island Homes and Condos for Sale

Middle Island is a charming hamlet and census designated place (CDP) in the alluring Town of Brookhaven. Located in Suffolk County in Long Island, New York, the hamlet of Middle Island is a great place to call home. At the time of the 2010 census, Middle Island had a population of approximately 10,483 residents. The hamlet has a total area of 8.3 square miles with 8.2 square miles being land and the remainder being water. The hamlet’s name is reference to its location halfway between the eastern and western ends of Long Island, as well as it being halfway between Long Island Sound to the north and the Atlantic Ocean to the south. In addition to a great location, the hamlet also has a rich history. The beginning of European-American history in the area can be traced back to 1766 when the First Presbyterian Church was built. The pastor, who was also a doctor, would ride horseback to visit congregants of his immense parish. He carried Bibles and medicine in his saddle bags. In 1813, the first schoolhouse was erected. 

This family friendly community not only has a rich history, but also boasts excellent schools and ample opportunities for recreation. The children of Middle Island attend schools in the Longwood Central School District which is the largest district on the island. Additionally, there are three public golf course in Middle Island. Cathedral Pines County Park and Prosser Pines County Park are both in the hamlet as well as Spring Lake, Artist Lake, and Pine Lake. The headwaters of the Carmans River are also in Middle Island.

Homes for sale in Middle Island come in a broad price range and include properties of various sizes and homes of varying ages and styles. Condominiums, townhomes, single family homes, and lots on which to build your custom home are all available in the hamlet of Middle Island. The average price for a Middle Island condo is about $166,100. The average listing price for a single family home in Middle Island is around $283,400. However, some Middle Island homes can sell for as much as $489,000, or more.

If you would like to learn more about the homes for sale in Middle Island, New York, please do not hesitate to contact us today.

Latest Middle Island Homes and Condos for Sale

440 Middle Country  Road, Middle Island image
440 Middle Country Road, Middle Island $3,400,000 ▼

Investors get ready. This Legal 7 family is a renter's dream. Everything is brand new. A single tenant is leasing the entire property with a long-term lease of 5 years. P...

  • 8 Beds
  • 8 Baths
  • 3455923 MLS
395 Middle Country  Road, Middle Island image
395 Middle Country Road, Middle Island $1,200,000

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! 2,560 Sqft. Auto Repair Shop On A HUGE 10,890 Sqft. Corner Lot For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellen...

  • 3465310 MLS
34 Middle Island  Boulevard, Middle Island image
34 Middle Island Boulevard, Middle Island $699,000 ▲

Brand new year of 2020 property sit on 2.25 acres w/spectacular sunrises & sunsets. Modern floor plan for the new owner. Main floor boasts hardwood floor through out, ope...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3450966 MLS
6 Greenway  Drive, Middle Island image
6 Greenway Drive, Middle Island $650,000 ▲

Spacious Colonial on a shy half acre has newly updated Primary Bath, hardwood floors, custom millwork, Anderson Windows, Central Air Conditioning, Eat-in-Kitchen with sta...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3460794 MLS
LOT 4 Currans  Road, Middle Island image
LOT 4 Currans Road, Middle Island $649,990

CONSTRUCTION UNDER WAY!!!2 HOMES LEFT IN THIS 4 LOT/ FLAG LOT LOCATION!!!!! THIS TO BE BUILT 5 BEDROOM/2 1/2 BATHROOM COLONIAL NEW CONSTRUCTION HOME TO BE BUILT/ CONSTRU...

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3454200 MLS
55 Lot 1 Middle Island  Boulevard, Middle Island image
55 Lot 1 Middle Island Boulevard, Middle Island $629,999 ▲

Customize your Brand New Construction in a subdiviosn that feels like the middle of the woods in upstate NY! Engage and connect with specialized, family owned and operat...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3436930 MLS
LOT 3 Currans  Road, Middle Island image
LOT 3 Currans Road, Middle Island $629,990

CONSTRUCTION UNDER WAY!!2 HOMES LEFT IN THIS 4 LOT/ FLAG LOT LOCATION!!!!! THIS TO BE BUILT 5 BEDROOM/3 FULL BATHROOM COLONIAL NEW CONSTRUCTION HOME TO BE BUILT/ CONSTRUC...

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3445400 MLS
N/C Cedar Branch, Middle Island image
N/C Cedar Branch, Middle Island $599,990

THIS TO BE BUILT 3 BEDROOM COLONIAL WITH 2 FULL BATHROOMS/ ONE HALF BATHROOM/ FULL UNFINISHED BASEMENT WITH 8 FT. CEILINGS / EAT IN KITCHEN/DINING RM./ GREAT RM/ OAK FL...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3435335 MLS
Lot 4 Bunker  Lane, Middle Island image
Lot 4 Bunker Lane, Middle Island $590,000 ▲

Magnificent New Construction To Be Built_ Private Shared Drive. Various Models To Choose From-Raised Ranch, Colonials, Victorians-Harwood Floors On First Floor, Granite K...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3191650 MLS
Lot 2 Bunker  Lane, Middle Island image
Lot 2 Bunker Lane, Middle Island $580,000 ▲

Welcome To Cedar Ridge Estates! - Raised Ranch, Colonials, Victorians~ Hardwood Floors On First Floor, Granite Kitchen Counter-Tops, Beautiful Cabinets With Dovetail Draw...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3191585 MLS
10 Ethan  Circle Unit #10, Middle Island image
10 Ethan Circle Unit #10, Middle Island — Birchwood At Spring Lake $539,999

Move right In to this beautifully updated home. Located at Birchwood at Spring Lake gated community.Enter into the grand living room area w/ vaulted ceilings. Custom eat ...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3460348 MLS
  • Birchwood At Spring Lake Bldg.
58 Winterberry  Drive, Middle Island image
58 Winterberry Drive, Middle Island $539,000 ▲

Amazing Colonial that will not last! This home is well maintained with a grand entry to the formal sitting room with natural lighting. Accompanied with a lovely formal di...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3464643 MLS
Old Middle Count  Road, Middle Island image
Old Middle Count Road, Middle Island $499,000

zoned A1 residential. Town of Brookhaven represented 3 lot subdivision with variance, that matches surrounding area. Buyer is responsible to verify all info

  • 3368138 MLS
31 Creekside  Drive, Middle Island image
31 Creekside Drive, Middle Island $480,000 ▲

BACK ON THE MARKET/SHORT SALE/ - BEAUTIFUL SECLUDED SUBDIVISION / great location , lots of privacy , feature: living room , den, large kitchen,3 bedrooms, 2 full bath , ...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3445655 MLS
38 Oakcrest  Avenue, Middle Island image
38 Oakcrest Avenue, Middle Island $469,990

This Home Nestled On Half An Acre With A Oversized 2 Car Detached Garage With With So Many Possibilities! The Gleaming Wood Floors Lead You Through The Formal Living Room...

  • 4 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3461157 MLS
9 Lavern  Drive Unit #9, Middle Island image
9 Lavern Drive Unit #9, Middle Island — Birchwood@Spring Lake $469,900

STUNNING 2023 Completely renovated 2bd, 2full bath Quad with vaulted ceilings, loft, primary bedroom w/full bath on 1st floor. The Spa like bathroom features a double van...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3464254 MLS
  • Birchwood@Spring Lake Bldg.
10 Woodville  Road, Middle Island image
10 Woodville Road, Middle Island $449,888

Beautiful Move In Ready Newly Renovated 3 Bdrm 2 Bath Home with Newly Refinished Hardwood Floors, Central Air, Just Renovated Bath with Beautiful Soaker Tub, Brand New Wi...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3462108 MLS
5 Ethan  Circle Unit #5, Middle Island image
5 Ethan Circle Unit #5, Middle Island — Birchwood $439,900 ▲

Enjoy Country Club Living! Spacious 2Br 2. Bath Devon Ranch with Custom Fireplace, Ceramic Tile, Granite Kitchen, Hi Hats And New Hot Water Heater. Amenities Include: 9 ...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3437047 MLS
  • Birchwood Bldg.
10 Poinsetta  Avenue, Middle Island image
10 Poinsetta Avenue, Middle Island $429,900

This Colonial Style Home Features 4 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen & 1 Car Garage. The information provided is estimated to the best of our ab...

  • 4 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3461380 MLS
209 Dorado N Court Unit #209, Middle Island image
209 Dorado N Court Unit #209, Middle Island — Strathmore On The Green $419,999

Welcome Home to Strathmore on the Green! A gated community offering 24 hour security, guard booth, community pool, playground and tennis court. HOA monthly fee is $395.00...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3462948 MLS
  • Strathmore On The Green Bldg.
866 Birchwood Park  Drive Unit #n/a, Middle Island image
866 Birchwood Park Drive Unit #n/a, Middle Island — Birchwood @ Spring Lake $399,999 ▼

Looking for a true move in ready, one level-end unit- home in prestigious Birchwood At Spring Lake? Then look no further. This remodeled and immaculate open concept home...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3456840 MLS
  • Birchwood @ Spring Lake Bldg.
59 Eric  Drive Unit #59, Middle Island image
59 Eric Drive Unit #59, Middle Island — Birchwood@Spring Lake $399,990 ▼

Beautiful, Spacious Galaxy Unit with a Stunning View of the Golf Course. Located in the desirable Birchwood at Spring Lake Development. Includes 1 Car Detached Garage, Ne...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3457103 MLS
  • Birchwood@Spring Lake Bldg.
95 Rocky Point  Road, Middle Island image
95 Rocky Point Road, Middle Island $399,990

This home is perfect for buyers with all types of uses in the past detached heated structure was used as a dog kennel, since has been updated perfect to live in home and ...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3445314 MLS
Lot Evergreen - Oakc  Avenue, Middle Island image
Lot Evergreen - Oakc Avenue, Middle Island $399,000

Beautiful 3 lots with possible subdivision . Nice corner location close to Pine Lake.

  • 3465768 MLS
885 Spring Lake  Drive Unit #885, Middle Island image
885 Spring Lake Drive Unit #885, Middle Island — Birchwood At Spring Lake $385,000 ▼

Move right in! 24/7 Gated Community Desirable end unit renovated in 2023. All new floors on lower levely, Freshly painted, Spotless. Private 9 hole golf course, putting ...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3460999 MLS
  • Birchwood At Spring Lake Bldg.
5 Pine  Road, Middle Island image
5 Pine Road, Middle Island $369,900

Welcome to 5 Pine Rd. This beautifully remodeled top to bottom ranch home features 3 bedroom one full bath with an open concept living space for modern amenities. Enjoy t...

  • 3 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • H6234193 MLS
20 Park  Lane, Middle Island image
20 Park Lane, Middle Island $325,000 ▼

Remodeled in 2018 with a new roof, siding and windows. Eat in kitchen features stainless steel appliances. Spacious bedrooms and wood floors. Large yard for entertaining....

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3364405 MLS
230 Fairview  Circle Unit #230, Middle Island image
230 Fairview Circle Unit #230, Middle Island — Artist Lake $309,990

This Beverly Unit Includes A Covered Front Porch For Convenience And Storage. You Enter Into The Large Spacious Living Room With An Eat In Kitchen Which Opens To A Formal...

  • 2 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3460647 MLS
  • Artist Lake Bldg.
80 Wilson  Avenue, Middle Island image
80 Wilson Avenue, Middle Island $265,000

This home is a ranch style and offers 3 Bedrooms and 1 Full Bathroom, Living Room, Eat In Kitchen and Laundry area. House has a lot of potential and it Is located in a co...

  • 3 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3463601 MLS
192 Artist Lake  Drive Unit #192, Middle Island image
192 Artist Lake Drive Unit #192, Middle Island — Artist Lake $175,000

rented 1 Bedroom 1 Bath condo is Artist Lake being sold as is with the tenant

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3462417 MLS
  • Artist Lake Bldg.
34 Bailey  Court Unit #34, Middle Island image
34 Bailey Court Unit #34, Middle Island — Hidden Meadows $170,000

Welcome home, sweet home! Why rent when you can buy? Don't miss this meticiously maintained upper level co-op in the lovely Hidden Meadows community. Cherry cabinets wi...

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3465494 MLS
  • Hidden Meadows Bldg.
98 Bailey Court Unit #98, Middle Island image
98 Bailey Court Unit #98, Middle Island — Hidden Meadows $165,000 ▲

Just renovated. Move right in! New carpet, new kitchen counter, cabinets and flooring. New hot water heater. New bathroom vanity and tub. Open floor plan. Bright and spac...

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3385660 MLS
  • Hidden Meadows Bldg.
132 Bailey  Court Unit #132, Middle Island image
132 Bailey Court Unit #132, Middle Island — Hidden Meadows $162,000

Here's your opportunity to purchase a co-op in the beautiful Hidden Meadows community. Large, spacious rooms. Laminate flooring. Community amenities include on-site la...

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3455473 MLS
  • Hidden Meadows Bldg.
223 Artist Lake  Drive Unit #Upper, Middle Island image
223 Artist Lake Drive Unit #Upper, Middle Island — Artist Lake $162,000 ▲

Upper Unit,1 Bedroom 1 Bath, CAC, Hardwood Floors & Great Closet Space. Convenient To Parking, Amenities, Pool, Club House, Gym, Tennis & Playground! Open house canceled ...

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3423886 MLS
  • Artist Lake Bldg.
Francis  Boulevard, Middle Island image
Francis Boulevard, Middle Island $160,000

This is a wooded vacant flag lot, located behind another vacant lot at the end of a cul-de-sac.

  • 3442586 MLS
86 Bailey  Court Unit #86, Middle Island image
86 Bailey Court Unit #86, Middle Island — Hidden Meadows $152,000

HIDDEN MEADOWS Welcomes you. Quiet Community closely located to shopping and restaurants. Nice upper unit with private balcony. Multiple closets, Community offers clubhou...

  • 1 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3464300 MLS
  • Hidden Meadows Bldg.
Devon  Lane, Middle Island image
Devon Lane, Middle Island $149,000

Multi Use Lot. Allows For 1-2 Family Dwelling - Zoned J Business.

  • 3461820 MLS

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.

Like or Share
Loading likes...

Town of Hempstead

  • Atlantic Beach
  • Baldwin
  • Bellmore
  • Bellerose Terrace
  • Bethpage
  • East Meadow
  • East Rockaway
  • Elmont
  • Hewlett & Five Towns
  • Floral Park
  • Franklin Square
  • Freeport
  • Garden City
  • Hempstead
  • Island Park
  • Levittown
  • Lynbrook
  • Malverne
  • Merrick
  • Mineola
  • New Hyde Park
  • North Valley Stream
  • Oceanside
  • Point Lookout
  • Rockville Centre
  • Roosevelt
  • Seaford
  • Uniondale
  • Valley Stream
  • Wantagh
  • West Hempstead

Town of Oyster Bay

  • Bayville
  • Bethpage/Old Bethpage
  • Brookville's
  • Centre Island
  • Cove Neck
  • East Norwich
  • Farmingdale
  • Glen Head
  • Glenwood Landing
  • Hicksville
  • Jericho
  • Lattingtown
  • Laurel Hollow
  • Locust Valley
  • Massapequa
  • Massapequa Park
  • Matinecock
  • Mill Neck
  • Muttontown
  • Old Westbury
  • Oyster Bay
  • Plainview
  • Sea Cliff
  • Seaford
  • Syosset
  • Woodbury

City of Long Beach

City of Glen Cove

Town of Babylon

  • Amityville
  • Babylon
  • Copaigue
  • Deer Park
  • Lindenhurst
  • North Amityville
  • North Babylon
  • West Babylon
  • Wyandanch

Town of Brookhaven

  • Bellport
  • Blue Point
  • Brookhaven
  • Calverton
  • CenterReach
  • Center Moriches
  • Coram
  • East Moriches
  • East Patchogue
  • Eastport
  • Farmingville
  • Holbrook
  • Holtsville
  • Lake Grove
  • Manorville
  • Mastic
  • Mastic Beach
  • Medford
  • Middle Island
  • Miller Place
  • Moriches
  • Mount Sinai
  • North Patchoque
  • Old Field
  • Patchogue
  • Poquott
  • Port Jefferson
  • Port Jefferson Station
  • Ridge
  • Rocky Point
  • Ronkonkoma
  • Selden
  • Setauket/E. Setauket
  • Shirley
  • Shoreham
  • Sound Beach
  • Stony Brook
  • Wading River
  • Yaphank

Town of Huntington

  • Asharoken
  • Centerport
  • Cold Spring Harbor
  • Commack
  • Dix Hills
  • Elwood
  • Fort Salonga
  • Greenlawn
  • Huntington
  • Huntington Station
  • Lloyd Harbor
  • Melville
  • Northport/East Northport

Town of Smithtown

  • Commack
  • Hauppague
  • Kings Park
  • Nesconset
  • Smithtown
  • St. James

Town of Islip

  • Bayport
  • Bay Shore
  • Bohemia
  • Brentwood
  • Brightwaters
  • Central Islip
  • East Islip
  • Great River
  • Hauppague
  • Holbrook
  • Holtsville
  • Islandia
  • Islip
  • Oakdale
  • Ocean Beach
  • Ronkonkoma
  • Sayville/West Sayville
  • West Islip

Town of Southhampton

  • Bridgehampton
  • Eastport
  • East Quogue
  • Hampton Bays
  • Quogue
  • Remsenberg
  • Sag Harbor
  • Sagaponack
  • Southampton
  • Speonk
  • Water Mill
  • Westhampton
  • Westhampton Beach

Town of East Hampton

  • Amagansett
  • East Hampton
  • Montauk
  • Sag Harbor
  • Wainscott

Town of Shelter Island

  • Shelter Island
  • Shelter Island Heights

Town of Riverhead

  • Aquebogue
  • Calverton
  • Jamesport
  • Laurel
  • Manorville
  • Northville
  • Riverhead
  • South Jamesport
  • Wading River

Town of Southold

  • Cutchogue
  • East Marion
  • Fishers Island
  • Greenport
  • Laurel
  • Mattituck
  • New Suffolk
  • Orient
  • Peconic
  • Southold

Town of North Hempstead

  • Baxter Estates
  • Carle Place
  • East Hills
  • Garden City Park
  • Great Neck
  • Greenvale
  • Herricks
  • Kings Point
  • Lake Success
  • Manhasset
  • Mineola
  • New Hyde Park
  • North Hills
  • Old Westbury
  • Plandome
  • Port Washington
  • Roslyn
  • Roslyn Heights
  • Sands Point
  • Westbury
  • Williston Park & Albertson
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • Map Search
  • What's My Home Worth?
  • Sellers
  • Meet The Team
  • Blog

About

The Pesce & Lanzillotta Team

Berkshire Hathaway Laffey International

8223 Jericho Tpke

Woodbury, NY 11797

Office: 516-888-9711

© All Rights Reserved - Privacy Policy - DMCA Notice

Cobblestone Realty

Services

  • Buy a Home
  • Sell a Home
  • Our Team testimonials
  • See What Your Home is Worth
  • Search

Follow Us

facebook instagram

Download Our App

App Store iconp
    Play Store icon

Our Partners:

  • Double Eagle Agency, Insurance Provider
  • Michael J. Fedele, ESQ.
  • The Pesce & Lanzillotta Team, at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices
  • Lynx Mortgage Bank
IDX Real Estate Websites by
• Accessibility • Terms • Privacy