Middle Island, nestled within the captivating Town of Brookhaven in Suffolk County, Long Island, New York, offers a picturesque blend of history, community, and modern amenities. With a population of approximately 10,483 residents as of the 2010 census, this charming hamlet spans 8.3 square miles, with the majority being land, and a sprinkling of water features adding to its allure.
Named for its central position between the eastern and western extremities of Long Island, as well as its equidistance from the Long Island Sound and the Atlantic Ocean, Middle Island wears its geographic significance proudly. Its legacy dates back to 1766 with the establishment of the First Presbyterian Church, marking the onset of European-American settlement. The hamlet's rich tapestry of history includes tales of horseback-riding pastors doubling as doctors, carrying both Bibles and remedies in their saddlebags. In 1813, Middle Island further cemented its community ethos with the construction of its first schoolhouse.
For families seeking an enriching environment, Middle Island delivers on education and recreation alike. Children benefit from the acclaimed Longwood Central School District, the largest on Long Island, ensuring access to quality education. Amidst the natural splendor of Middle Island, residents enjoy three public golf courses and a plethora of parks including Cathedral Pines County Park, Prosser Pines County Park, and the serene Spring Lake, Artist Lake, and Pine Lake. The headwaters of the Carmans River add to the hamlet's scenic allure, offering opportunities for exploration and outdoor activities.
Real estate in Middle Island caters to diverse preferences and budgets. Prospective homeowners can choose from an array of housing options including condominiums, townhomes, single-family dwellings, and vacant lots for custom builds. The median price for a condo in Middle Island hovers around $166,100, while single-family homes typically list at an average of $283,400. However, the market also presents opportunities for upscale living, with some homes fetching upwards of $489,000 or more.
Beyond its historical charm and natural beauty, Middle Island thrives as a vibrant community, offering residents a harmonious blend of small-town tranquility and modern conveniences. Whether you're drawn to its rich heritage, top-notch schools, recreational amenities, or diverse real estate options, Middle Island beckons with the promise of a fulfilling lifestyle.
For those eager to explore the homes for sale in Middle Island, New York, our team stands ready to assist. Contact us today to embark on your journey to finding your dream home in this enchanting hamlet.
Great Location and Property w/ 2650 Sq Ft Building and 10,890 Sq ft lot w/ 38 Parking Spaces. 3 Options tp Purchase: Building Purchase $850,000. Building has 2 Bays, 16 ...
Charming Horse Property with Cottage on 2+ Acres Next to Rocky Point Preserve! This scenic 2+ acre property offers a mix of country charm and equestrian amenities. The Ex...
Welcome to the pride of Middle Island. Imagine no gas , no oil or electric bills ! This 3000+ sqft to be built geothermal and solar colonial masterpiece has what you've ...
what a rare find is this large ranch on a 6 acre parcel with endless possibilities. home is very well maintained with large rooms, some of the updates over the years are ...
Introducing a stunning custom-built Colonial that seamlessly blends historic charm with modern comfort. This home features a chef's kitchen boasting quartz countertops, a...
Welcome to your dream home! This 4 bedroom colonial residence, nestled on a sprawling 0.61-acre lot, offers the perfect blend of charm and spaciousness. This property is ...
To Be Built. Photo Shown Conveys Craftsmanship of Model To Be Built. Amenities included are hardwood floors on the first floor with carpet in the bedrooms, granite kitche...
To Be Built. Photo Shown Conveys Craftsmanship of Model To Be Built. Amenities included are hardwood floors on the first floor with carpet in the bedrooms, granite kitche...
This charming colonial home, complete with a wrap-around porch, is situated in a lovely development on just under an acre of land. The main level features a formal living...
The Home Of Your Dreams Is Waiting For You! Living Room Perfect For Entertaining Your Guests, Kitchen To Prepare All Your Meals, 4 Spacious Bedrooms And 2 Full Bathrooms!...
Welcome to this beautiful updated Hampton model home in BirchWood at Spring Lake in Middle Island. This Spacious home features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms. The primary s...
This Is A True Four Bedroom Center Hall colonial, This Home Is Nestled On A Full Acre, Upon Entering The Home Living Room Is On The Right, Formal Dining Room Is On The Le...
Welcome to this spacious colonial w 1st floor featuring 1 bedroom1 bath dining room living room eat in kitchen sliding doors off kitchen leading to a relaxing deck w/ bui...
Enjoy Country Club Living! Great Location! An opportunity to join Birchwood at Spring Lake with amenities that include a private 9 Hole Private Golf Course, 2 Clubhouses...
Updated 3 bedroom 2 bath ranch in the heart of Middle Island-home to beautiful Spring Lake Golf Course. Kitchen offers tons of cabinets, stainless steel appliances and gr...
Your Search Ends At 14 Elkin Dr.! Meticulously Maintained and Absolutely Pristine Ranch! Curb Lined Streets & Underground Utilities, Primary Bedroom With Walk-in Closet &...
Come See This Beautiful 3BR, 1.5 Bath Ranch Style Home. Newly Updated Eat-In-Kitchen. Featuring Finished Basement w/ Walkout Access, Sitting on .64 Acres.
Three LOTS included in this ONE PURCHASE, offering many land use options! A GREAT Opportunity to buy PRIVACY (w/ 1.5 Acres) PLUS a SOLID HOUSE w/ a flexible floor plan. T...
Charming 3-Bedroom, 1-Bathroom Home Welcome to your ideal primary residence, offering a blend of comfort, functionality, and potential for personalization. This delightf...
Enjoy Country Club Living! Spacious 3 Bedroom 2.5 Bath Malibu Model With Updates That Include: Granite Kitchen, New Baths, Wood Flooring: Newer Heat And CAC, Hi Hat Light...
Beautiful 3 Bedroom 2.5 Bath Townhouse Located on the Birchwood at Spring Lake Private Golf Course. Stunning Sunsets & views of the golf course! Sunny Eat-n-Kitchen wit...
Welcome Home to 17 Saddlebrook Court in Strathmore on the Green. This desirable Briar Hollow Model offers an open floor plan with the choice of having your Primary Bedroo...
Welcome To Strathmore On The Green, A Gated Community! This Beautifully Remodeled 2 Bedroom Single Family Home Includes A Loft/Den (Possible 3 Bedroom). The Grand Formal ...
Welcome To Strathmore On The Green, A Gated Community! This Beautifully Remodeled 2 Bedroom Single Family Home Includes A Loft/Den (Possible 3 Bedroom). The Grand Formal ...
Welcome to Strathmore on The Green. Beautiful 3 Bedroom 2.5 bath single unit Pine Ridge model located on a cul-de-sac. As you come in the bright living room with high cei...
Welcome to Strathmore on The Green. Beautiful 3 Bedroom 2.5 bath single unit Pine Ridge model located on a cul-de-sac. As you come in the bright living room greets you wi...
Move right into this gorgeous 3 bedroom 2.5 bathroom Malibu Model Townhouse with a Garage in Birchwood at Spring Lake! Walk right in to your spacious living room, dining ...
Quaint Cottage situated on nice size park like grounds. The home boasts 1/2 bedrooms, 1 bath, fireplace, EIK and dining area. The home also has a large 1 car garage to st...
Welcome to this beautiful home with a sleek, neutral color scheme. The kitchen is a chef's delight, featuring a stylish backsplash and all-new stainless steel appliances....
Beautiful, Spacious Galaxy Unit with a Stunning View of the Golf Course. Located in the desirable Birchwood at Spring Lake Development. Entrance hall, Eat-n-Kitchen, Livi...
Come and claim your home in the private community of Coventry Manor. The amenities includes, Clubhouse, Tennis court, Playground, and Swimming pool. All's that needed id...
Discover a peaceful retreat in this first-floor end-unit condo within the coveted Artist Lake community. This stylish home features gleaming hardwood floors, an open-conc...
Welcome to 243 Fairview Circle, a brand-new construction second-floor condo unit located in the heart of Middle Island. This home offers two bedrooms and two bathrooms on...
Welcome to 106 Fairview Circle! This charming highly desirable 2 bedroom and 2 full bathroom second-floor corner unit. The condo is a true gem, offering a bright and ai...
Step into this stunning upper condominium boasting beautiful hardwood flooring throughout, a hallmark of timeless elegance and durability. The moment you enter, you're gr...
Perfect Lower Unit 2 bedrooms, 1 1/2 bath Condo. Newer kitchen w/white cabinetry, quartz countertops and Ss appliances. Lets not forget the updated bathrooms. Dining Ar...
Great Updated Corner End Unit close to Clubhouse and Pool! Some updates include paint, most appliances & flooring, both bedrooms are large, Master has half bath, 2 closet...
Welcome to the charming Artist Lake Condo Complex! This main floor-corner condo is perfectly situated in a beautiful and peaceful community offering convenience and comf...
Look no more! Large 2br, 2 full bath condo corner unit on the 1st floor with patio! ALL utilities are included except electric,ales it great to budget! Grounds are beauti...
Welcome to 14 Fairview Circle, a delightful 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath condo perfect for comfortable living. This lovely home features a cozy small patio, ideal for morning coff...
1.46 Acres, with Suffolk County Board Health & Town of Brookhaven Planning Board approval.!!
Very desirable upper corner unit!! Bright and spacious with 2 full baths! There's plenty of storage, a patio overlooking the grounds and plenty of parking for guests!! ...
Investor special! This 4-bedroom, 1-bath Cape at 35 Adams Lane in Middle Island, New York, offers significant potential for those looking to renovate and add value. Situa...
Welcome to the renowned Artist Lake Condominiums. Come see this second floor end unit for yourself and experience the sun drenched spacious rooms. You will enjoy the cl...
Build your dream home on this 1 acre land on flag lot with approvals ! No need for contingencies, ready to go !!
Welcome to this well-maintained Astor model in the desirable 24/7 gated community at Artist Lake. This first-floor unit offers an inviting exterior with beautifully lands...
Great Opportunity to Own a 30 Year Established Auto Repair Business. 2 Bays with Lifts. Waiting Room with Storage room and Bathroom. Lease $7800. Building Purchase optio...
Welcome to easy living at its best! This charming co-op is perfectly situated in a peaceful cul-de-sac, offering convenience and comfort with stunning water views. Locate...
Nestled in a quiet well-manicured courtyard this upstairs unit offers a large bedroom with plenty of closet space, sizeable Living Room/Dining Room combo, one full bathro...
This unit is ready for you to move in. Lovely open space with kitchen, eating area and living space. Bedroom that leads out to your patio. CAC. Beautifully updated bathro...
Beautiful, move in ready one bedroom, one bathroom unit in Hidden Meadows. Rare end unit with a kitchen window view. Brand new A/C Unit. New Floors. New Kitchen. Redone B...
Information Copyright 2024, OneKey® MLS. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey® MLS.