Long Island Real Estate | Long Island Homes for Sale
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • Map Search
  • What's My Home Worth?
  • Sellers
  • Meet The Team
  • Blog
Login
516-888-9711

Sign in to your account

Need to reset your phone number?

Don't have an account with us?

Click here to sign up.

Shelter Island Real Estate Search

TO
Advanced Search

Address Search

Shelter Island Homes and Condos for Sale

At the eastern end of Long Island you will find the renowned Shelter Island, New York. Shelter Island is both a town and an island. Though separated by water, Shelter Island is part of Suffolk County and according to the 2010 Census, has a population around 2,400 residents. Composed of roughly 8,000 acres, Shelter Island is situated between the North and South Forks of Long Island. On one side it bordered by Gardiners Bay and on the other three sides it is surrounded by Shelter Island Sound. Via ferry Greenport is an approximate eight minute trip to the north and North Haven is an approximate five minute trip south. Running through the island you’ll find New York State Route 114.

Nearly one-third of Shelter Island is owned by The Nature Conservancy and vast tracts of the island are protected wetlands and preserved marshland. The Preserve has four scenic bird-watching and nature trails of varying lengths. There is also a barrier-free Braille trail for visitors with visual impairments. Shelter Island is also home to several smaller communities, neighborhoods and subdivisions. Among them you’ll find Dering Harbor, Harbor View, Montclair Colony, Shelter Island Heights, Silver Beach, Westmoreland, and Nostrand Parkway.

Homes for sale in Shelter Island include a variety of styles, ages and sizes. You can easily find charming coastal homes, gorgeous Victorians, manors, ranch cottages, large estates, and more. Vacant lots and plots of land for sale in Shelter Island have varying listing prices depending upon the property’s size and location. The average listing price for land in Shelter Island is $681,400 but some lots can list for $889,000 or more. Single family homes for sale in Shelter Island have an average listing price around $1.4 million with some Shelter Island homes listing for more than $5.3 million.

If you would like more information regarding homes for sale in Shelter Island, New York, please do not hesitate to contact us today.

Latest Shelter Island Homes and Condos for Sale

90 Peconic  Avenue, Shelter Island image
90 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island $3,500,000 ▼

On Peconic Bay side of Shelter Island Sound with 190 feet of waterfront with sandy beach, bulkhead and dock. This 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath beautiful shingle beach house on an ...

  • 5 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • 3221220 MLS
24 Midway  Road, Shelter Island image
24 Midway Road, Shelter Island $2,950,000 ▼

This stunning freshly renovated waterfront home with detached guest apartment and garage could be your new refuge. The open plan living area with vaulted ceiling steps on...

  • 5 Beds
  • 5 Baths
  • 3271725 MLS
47B Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
47B Ferry Road, Shelter Island $2,950,000

Waterfront home nestled in our treasured Nature Preserve. This cozy 3 bedroom 2 bath home has breathtaking views of Coecles Harbor. With your own private beach and dock y...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • 3260204 MLS
87 Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
87 Ferry Road, Shelter Island $2,390,000

Incredible Business Opportunity on 1.62 Acres. This centrally located fully operational restaurant accommodates 56 seats, has a market, takeout counter, main dining room,...

  • 3281387 MLS
87 Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
87 Ferry Road, Shelter Island $2,390,000

Incredible Business Opportunity on 1.62 Acres. This centrally located fully operational restaurant accommodates 56 seats, has a market, takeout counter, main dining room,...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3281279 MLS
47L Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
47L Ferry Road, Shelter Island $2,195,000

With a breathtaking view east for sunrises towards Taylor's Island and sunsets to the west through the trees, this amazing property won't last. The tranquility of Coecles...

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3280948 MLS
47 Shore  Road, Shelter Island image
47 Shore Road, Shelter Island $1,950,000

Incredible bay-front panoramas from this elevated bluff above Shelter Island's Crescent Beach. A truly amazing location for your island dream home. Private, spacious & el...

  • 3278978 MLS
1 Sylvan  Road, Shelter Island image
1 Sylvan Road, Shelter Island $1,550,000 ▼

Superior Built Designer Showcase, Open Floor Plan, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, near beach with heated saltwater gunite pool, pergula dining patio, fenced gardens with mature lan...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3278713 MLS
35 Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
35 Ferry Road, Shelter Island $1,420,000 ▼

Not very often does a business site on Shelter Island come along for sale. With many different opportunities, this fantastic site located in the business zone can have ma...

  • 3223284 MLS
1 Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
1 Ferry Road, Shelter Island $1,399,000 ▼

Beautiful 1810 Greek Revival situated on large corner lot shy 1 acre. Makes a fabulous 2 family home with 3 living rooms, 2 kitchens, 5 bedrooms, 3 full bath and screene...

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • 3259938 MLS
32 Ram Island  Drive, Shelter Island image
32 Ram Island Drive, Shelter Island $1,350,000

Beautiful Estate Setting On The Historic Isle Of Shelter Island. Asserting A Total Of 9.74 Acres, The Property Faces South Directly On Coecles Harbor, Encompassing An Un...

  • 3291246 MLS
36 Ferry  Road, Shelter Island image
36 Ferry Road, Shelter Island $1,250,000

Great investment property with 3 offices and an apartment. This B1 Commercial multi use building, is centrally located and offers 2588 sq ft of space. All spaces are rent...

  • 3248293 MLS
29 St Marys  Road, Shelter Island image
29 St Marys Road, Shelter Island $1,150,000

Lovely flat 4 acre property. Level and partially cleared. Partially wooded at one time in cultivation with nursery stock. Mature nursery stock still exists on Southern ha...

  • 3278821 MLS
5 Tuthill  Drive, Shelter Island image
5 Tuthill Drive, Shelter Island $950,000 ▲

Exceptional & rare opportunity to build in a coveted & desirable setting on Tuthill Drive on Big Ram Island. A 1.6 acre partially cleared parcel awaits your custom built ...

  • 3239682 MLS
57 North Midway  Road, Shelter Island image
57 North Midway Road, Shelter Island $699,000

This 2.2 acre property allows for so many possibilities. The 1,546 sq foot ranch style home that site on the property is a 2 bedroom, 1 bath. The property also offers 1,2...

  • 2 Beds
  • 1 Baths
  • 3290528 MLS
8 Wheeler  Road, Shelter Island image
8 Wheeler Road, Shelter Island $595,000

Beautiful, level, wooded1.2 Acre lot in the Silver Beach Area waiting for your design and building ideas.Very close to boat ramp and Shell Beach. For viewing call Don Dun...

  • 3273646 MLS

Information Copyright 2016, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.

Like or Share
Loading likes...

Town of Hempstead

  • Atlantic Beach
  • Baldwin
  • Bellmore
  • Bellerose Terrace
  • Bethpage
  • East Meadow
  • East Rockaway
  • Elmont
  • Hewlett & Five Towns
  • Floral Park
  • Franklin Square
  • Freeport
  • Garden City
  • Hempstead
  • Island Park
  • Levittown
  • Lynbrook
  • Malverne
  • Merrick
  • Mineola
  • New Hyde Park
  • North Valley Stream
  • Oceanside
  • Point Lookout
  • Rockville Centre
  • Roosevelt
  • Seaford
  • Uniondale
  • Valley Stream
  • Wantagh
  • West Hempstead

Town of Oyster Bay

  • Bayville
  • Bethpage/Old Bethpage
  • Brookville's
  • Centre Island
  • Cove Neck
  • East Norwich
  • Farmingdale
  • Glen Head
  • Glenwood Landing
  • Hicksville
  • Jericho
  • Lattingtown
  • Laurel Hollow
  • Locust Valley
  • Massapequa
  • Massapequa Park
  • Matinecock
  • Mill Neck
  • Muttontown
  • Old Westbury
  • Oyster Bay
  • Plainview
  • Sea Cliff
  • Seaford
  • Syosset
  • Woodbury

City of Long Beach

City of Glen Cove

Town of Babylon

  • Amityville
  • Babylon
  • Copaigue
  • Deer Park
  • Lindenhurst
  • North Amityville
  • North Babylon
  • West Babylon
  • Wyandanch

Town of Brookhaven

  • Bellport
  • Blue Point
  • Brookhaven
  • Calverton
  • CenterReach
  • Center Moriches
  • Coram
  • East Moriches
  • East Patchogue
  • Eastport
  • Farmingville
  • Holbrook
  • Holtsville
  • Lake Grove
  • Manorville
  • Mastic
  • Mastic Beach
  • Medford
  • Middle Island
  • Miller Place
  • Moriches
  • Mount Sinai
  • North Patchoque
  • Old Field
  • Patchogue
  • Poquott
  • Port Jefferson
  • Port Jefferson Station
  • Ridge
  • Rocky Point
  • Ronkonkoma
  • Selden
  • Setauket/E. Setauket
  • Shirley
  • Shoreham
  • Sound Beach
  • Stony Brook
  • Wading River
  • Yaphank

Town of Huntington

  • Asharoken
  • Centerport
  • Cold Spring Harbor
  • Commack
  • Dix Hills
  • Elwood
  • Fort Salonga
  • Greenlawn
  • Huntington
  • Huntington Station
  • Lloyd Harbor
  • Melville
  • Northport/East Northport

Town of Smithtown

  • Commack
  • Hauppague
  • Kings Park
  • Nesconset
  • Smithtown
  • St. James

Town of Islip

  • Bayport
  • Bay Shore
  • Bohemia
  • Brentwood
  • Brightwaters
  • Central Islip
  • East Islip
  • Great River
  • Hauppague
  • Holbrook
  • Holtsville
  • Islandia
  • Islip
  • Oakdale
  • Ocean Beach
  • Ronkonkoma
  • Sayville/West Sayville
  • West Islip

Town of Southhampton

  • Bridgehampton
  • Eastport
  • East Quogue
  • Hampton Bays
  • Quogue
  • Remsenberg
  • Sag Harbor
  • Sagaponack
  • Southampton
  • Speonk
  • Water Mill
  • Westhampton
  • Westhampton Beach

Town of East Hampton

  • Amagansett
  • East Hampton
  • Montauk
  • Sag Harbor
  • Wainscott

Town of Shelter Island

  • Shelter Island
  • Shelter Island Heights

Town of Riverhead

  • Aquebogue
  • Calverton
  • Jamesport
  • Laurel
  • Manorville
  • Northville
  • Riverhead
  • South Jamesport
  • Wading River

Town of Southold

  • Cutchogue
  • East Marion
  • Fishers Island
  • Greenport
  • Laurel
  • Mattituck
  • New Suffolk
  • Orient
  • Peconic
  • Southold

Town of North Hempstead

  • Baxter Estates
  • Carle Place
  • East Hills
  • Garden City Park
  • Great Neck
  • Greenvale
  • Herricks
  • Kings Point
  • Lake Success
  • Manhasset
  • Mineola
  • New Hyde Park
  • North Hills
  • Old Westbury
  • Plandome
  • Port Washington
  • Roslyn
  • Roslyn Heights
  • Sands Point
  • Westbury
  • Williston Park & Albertson
  • Home
  • MLS Search
  • Map Search
  • What's My Home Worth?
  • Sellers
  • Meet The Team
  • Blog

About

The Pesce & Lanzillotta Team

Berkshire Hathaway Laffey International

8223 Jericho Tpke

Woodbury, NY 11797

Office: 516-888-9711

© All Rights Reserved - Privacy Policy - DMCA Notice

Cobblestone Realty

Services

  • Buy a Home
  • Sell a Home
  • Our Team testimonials
  • See What Your Home is Worth
  • Search

Follow Us

facebook instagram

Download Our App

app store icon play store icon

Our Partners:

  • Double Eagle Agency, Insurance Provider
  • Michael J. Fedele, ESQ.
  • The Pesce & Lanzillotta Team, at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices
  • Lynx Mortgage Bank
IDX Real Estate Websites by
• Accessibility