As more New Yorkers continue to prioritize space, lifestyle, flexibility, and long-term value, Long Island remains one of the most popular destinations for buyers leaving the city.

But today's buyers aren't all looking for the same thing.

Some want the shortest possible commute to Manhattan. Others are searching for waterfront living, top-rated schools, walkable downtowns, or larger homes with room to grow.

So where are NYC buyers moving on Long Island in 2026? Here are some of the communities attracting the most attention—and why buyers are choosing them.

Great Neck

For buyers who still commute into Manhattan several days a week, Great Neck remains one of Long Island's most desirable locations.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Great Neck

  • Fast access to Manhattan via the LIRR
  • Multiple train station options
  • Walkable neighborhoods in certain areas
  • Diverse housing inventory
  • Close proximity to Queens

Best For

Buyers who want to stay closely connected to New York City while enjoying suburban living.

Manhasset

Manhasset continues to attract professionals, executives, and families seeking convenience and long-term value.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Manhasset

  • Excellent commuter access
  • Strong housing demand
  • Beautiful residential neighborhoods
  • Upscale shopping and dining
  • Easy access to major roadways

Best For

Buyers looking for a polished suburban lifestyle with strong commuter convenience.

Port Washington

Port Washington remains one of the most popular relocation destinations on Long Island's North Shore.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Port Washington

  • Direct LIRR service to Manhattan
  • Waterfront lifestyle
  • Vibrant downtown
  • Marinas, parks, and outdoor recreation
  • Strong sense of community

Best For

Buyers seeking a balance between commuting convenience and coastal living.

Roslyn

Roslyn offers something many buyers struggle to find elsewhere: character.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Roslyn

  • Historic village atmosphere
  • Walkable downtown
  • Local restaurants and shops
  • Charming architecture
  • Strong community feel

Best For

Buyers who want a small-town feel without sacrificing accessibility.

Old Westbury

Luxury buyers continue to view Old Westbury as one of Long Island's premier addresses.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Old Westbury

  • Grand estate properties
  • Privacy and acreage
  • Gold Coast prestige
  • Country club lifestyle
  • Easy access to Manhattan

Best For

Buyers seeking classic North Shore luxury and estate living.

Brookville & Muttontown

The neighboring communities of Brookville and Muttontown have become increasingly attractive to buyers looking for more space and privacy.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Them

  • Larger lots
  • Quiet residential settings
  • Luxury homes
  • Natural surroundings
  • Estate-style living

Best For

Buyers who want privacy without leaving Nassau County.

Huntington

On Suffolk County's North Shore, Huntington continues to attract NYC buyers looking for a vibrant downtown and strong community atmosphere.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Huntington

  • Walkable downtown
  • Restaurants, nightlife, and local events
  • Variety of housing options
  • Strong sense of community
  • Convenient LIRR access

Best For

Buyers looking for a lively town with year-round activity.

Northport

Northport offers a picturesque waterfront village environment that appeals to many city buyers seeking a slower pace of life.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Northport

  • Charming harborfront setting
  • Walkable downtown
  • Local shops and restaurants
  • Strong community identity
  • Beautiful waterfront views

Best For

Buyers prioritizing lifestyle and charm over proximity to NYC.

Garden City

Garden City remains one of Long Island's most consistently popular communities.

Why NYC Buyers Are Choosing Garden City

  • Excellent schools
  • Beautiful neighborhoods
  • Convenient location
  • Strong commuter access
  • Established residential character

Best For

Buyers seeking a classic suburban experience with easy access to Manhattan.

Why Long Island Continues to Attract NYC Buyers

While every buyer's priorities are different, a few common themes continue to drive relocation decisions in 2026:

More Space

Many buyers are looking for larger homes, private outdoor space, and more room for family, work, and recreation.

Lifestyle

Waterfront living, walkable downtowns, parks, and community amenities remain major priorities.

Flexibility

The rise of hybrid work has expanded the range of communities buyers are willing to consider.

Long-Term Value

Many buyers view Long Island as a place where they can build equity while enjoying a high quality of life.

Which Long Island Town Is Right for You?

The answer depends on your priorities.

If commute time matters most:

  • Great Neck
  • Manhasset
  • Garden City

If lifestyle and community are your focus:

  • Port Washington
  • Roslyn
  • Huntington
  • Northport

If luxury and privacy are priorities:

  • Old Westbury
  • Brookville
  • Muttontown

If waterfront living is your goal:

  • Port Washington
  • Northport
  • Sands Point
  • Kings Point

Thinking About Moving from NYC to Long Island?

From commuter-friendly North Shore communities to waterfront villages and luxury estate neighborhoods, Long Island offers a wide range of options for today's buyers.

Understanding the differences between communities is often the key to finding the right fit—and making a move you'll be happy with for years to come.