If you’re thinking about leaving New York City for more space, better schools, or a quieter lifestyle, Long Island’s North Shore is one of the most sought-after destinations.

Known for its waterfront views, charming communities, and convenient access to Manhattan, the North Shore offers a wide range of options depending on your budget, lifestyle, and commute needs.

So, what are the best North Shore towns for NYC buyers in 2026? Here’s a breakdown of the top areas to consider—and how to choose the right one for you.

Port Washington: Best Overall for Lifestyle + Commuting

Port Washington consistently ranks as one of the top choices for NYC buyers—and for good reason.

  • Direct Long Island Rail Road access to Penn Station and Grand Central
  • Vibrant downtown with restaurants, cafes, and shops
  • Waterfront parks, marinas, and recreational options
  • Strong sense of community

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It offers the perfect balance of lifestyle, convenience, and accessibility.

Manhasset: Best for Convenience and Upscale Suburban Living

Manhasset is ideal for buyers who want a polished suburban feel with easy access to everything.

  • Close to major highways and NYC
  • Home to the Americana Manhasset
  • Well-maintained neighborhoods with strong property values
  • Highly convenient for commuting and daily errands

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It’s one of the most convenient North Shore towns without sacrificing quality or prestige.

Great Neck: Best for Commuters and Proximity to NYC

Great Neck is one of the closest North Shore communities to Manhattan, making it a top pick for frequent commuters.

  • Multiple LIRR stations with fast access to NYC
  • Diverse housing options, including co-ops and single-family homes
  • Walkable areas and strong local amenities
  • Excellent proximity to Queens

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
Shorter commute times and a more urban-suburban hybrid feel.

Old Westbury: Best for Estate Living and Privacy

For buyers looking for space, privacy, and luxury, Old Westbury stands out.

  • Expansive estates on large, private lots
  • Historic Gold Coast setting
  • Quiet, residential environment
  • Ideal for those seeking a more secluded lifestyle

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It offers a true escape from city living while still being within reach of Manhattan.

Brookville: Best for Understated Luxury

Brookville offers many of the same benefits as Old Westbury but with a slightly more relaxed feel.

  • Large properties surrounded by greenery
  • Mix of classic estates and newer construction
  • Quiet, low-density residential setting
  • Strong appeal for buyers seeking privacy without formality

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It feels exclusive without being overly formal or traditional.

Kings Point: Best for Ultra-Luxury Waterfront Living

Kings Point is one of the most prestigious communities on Long Island.

  • Waterfront estates and expansive properties
  • Highly private and residential
  • No commercial areas—focused entirely on luxury living
  • Close to Port Washington amenities

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It’s ideal for those seeking top-tier luxury and maximum privacy.

Roslyn: Best for Charm and Village Feel

Roslyn combines historic charm with modern convenience.

  • Walkable village center with restaurants and shops
  • Mix of older homes and updated properties
  • Easy access to highways and nearby towns
  • Strong sense of community

👉 Why NYC Buyers Love It:
It offers character, charm, and accessibility all in one place.

How to Choose the Right North Shore Town

The “best” town ultimately depends on what matters most to you.

If commute is your top priority:
Look at Great Neck, Manhasset, or Port Washington

If lifestyle and community matter most:
Port Washington or Roslyn

If you want space and privacy:
Old Westbury, Brookville, or Kings Point

If you’re looking for luxury:
Kings Point or Old Westbury

Final Thoughts: Best North Shore Towns for NYC Buyers

The North Shore offers something for nearly every type of NYC buyer—from waterfront lifestyle towns to private estate communities.

The key is finding the balance between commute, lifestyle, and budget that works for you.

Thinking About Moving from NYC to Long Island?

If you’re considering a move to the North Shore, having the right strategy can make all the difference—especially in a competitive market.

Reach out anytime to explore available homes, compare towns, and find the right fit for your next move.