Shelter Island Homes for Sale

Shelter Island Clear location

Interactive MapMap View
Refine Your SearchRefine Search
23 Properties
23 Properties
2 Quail Run
27 Lakeview Drive
20 Baldwin Road

Thinking about selling?

See what your home is worth today.

Enter Address
5 Marc
7 Wheeler Road
11 Jaspa Road
9 Bay Shore Drive
169 N Ferry Road
64A N Midway Road
6 Great Circle Drive
6 Oxford Avenue
5 Sea Gull Road
43 Gardiners Bay Drive
16 Bowditch Road
90 Peconic Avenue
2 Prospect Avenue
4 Irene Lane
11 Sunnyside Avenue